Exeter City Council asked for an equal seat on a new mayoral authority for Devon, Plymouth and Torbay. The final proposal gives the city a permanent seat, but not the same voting power as the three big councils.

The proposal goes to Plymouth City Council on Monday 23 November. Its councillors are recommended to agree that Plymouth joins the Devon and Torbay Combined County Authority, and that the authority gets a directly elected mayor. The first mayoral election would be in May 2028.

The papers for that meeting were published by Plymouth City Council. They include the results of the public consultation and the board structure the councils now want.

Overview

  • Exeter’s seat: one permanent seat, as a non-constituent member
  • Exeter’s vote: only on the functions the new board agrees at its first meeting
  • No vote at all on the mayor’s budget and council tax precept, the transport plan or the new strategic planning layer
  • Who decides: Plymouth (23 November), the authority’s board (25 November), Devon County Council (3 December) and Torbay Council (10 December). Exeter City Council does not get a vote on the proposal.
  • First mayor: elected in May 2028, if the government agrees

What Exeter asked for

In its consultation response dated 1 October, Exeter City Council backed a mayor. It also said any permanent model must give the city “an equal seat and equal decision-making power”. We reported the council’s response in October.

Devon County Council supported that ask. The consultation report says the county called for “a permanent place for Exeter City Council”.

What the proposal gives Exeter

The proposed board has 13 members. The cover report for Plymouth’s meeting sets them out:

Proposed board of the Mayoral Strategic Authority for Devon, Plymouth and Torbay
Appointed byMembersVotes
Devon County Council33
Plymouth City Council33
Torbay Council33
Devon's district councils (two) and Exeter City Council (one)3To be decided by the board
Directly elected mayor11

Business, skills, and possibly voluntary sector and health representatives would also sit on the board as associate members, without a vote.

Devon County Council, Plymouth and Torbay are the constituent councils. Exeter and the districts are not. In law, non-constituent members cannot vote unless the voting members agree to let them.

The proposal says the new authority would agree at its first meeting which functions Exeter and the districts could vote on.

What Exeter could never vote on

The law keeps some decisions for the mayor and the constituent members only. According to the report, they are:

  • changes to the authority’s membership, area, functions or constitution
  • scrutinising and amending the mayor’s budget and council tax precept
  • adopting the local transport plan
  • adopting the Spatial Development Strategy, a new layer of planning for housing need and broad locations for growth

Local plans and planning decisions would stay with the city council.

What the consultation found

The consultation ran from 16 September to 28 October. It drew 352 survey responses and 23 written responses, according to the consultation report.

  • Plymouth joining: 60% agreed and 33% disagreed
  • A mayor: 63% supported and 36% opposed
  • Respondents in Devon outside Plymouth: 73% backed Plymouth joining

Exeter’s position was a recurring theme. Of the 231 people who answered the question on governance, 10 raised it. It also came up in 13 answers about concerns over Plymouth joining, and 17 about a mayor. The report concludes that organisations want arrangements “recognising the role of Exeter within strategic decision-making”.

South Hams and West Devon councils said they would not support a mayoral authority unless district councils get full voting rights.

The report says a cross-authority group of councillors working on governance is “the natural place” to respond to the points on representation.

What happens next

The proposal can go to the government only once four bodies have each consented:

  1. Plymouth City Council, on 23 November
  2. The authority’s board, on 25 November
  3. Devon County Council, on 3 December
  4. Torbay Council, on 10 December

The aim is to submit it before the end of 2026, so the government can make regulations in early 2027. The government named Devon, Plymouth and Torbay in its new wave of devolution on 28 October, subject to local consent.

What it means for you

  • A mayor would have powers over Exeter’s buses and transport plan. The mayor would also decide on bus franchising and prepare the strategic plan for housing growth.
  • A mayor could add a charge to council tax, called a precept. It would be subject to the constituent councils’ power of veto. Exeter City Council’s board member would not have a vote on it.
  • Bins, planning applications and other city services stay with Exeter City Council. The report says the authority “would not take over council services”.
  • You can follow the decision on Plymouth’s City Council agenda for 23 November.

Sources